Biggest Signs That Your Potential Roommate Isn’t Right For You

Share this article:

Choosing a roommate is like finding a new best friend to share your fridge, your living room and fight over the TV with — so, like a sibling you share rent with. But while you can’t choose your sibling, you can definitely choose your roommate. That’s why it’s important to keep an eye out for some big roommate red flags when it comes to the selection process.

But what exactly should you look for? First, poor communication skills can turn simple chats into frustrating guessing games. Then there’s financial instability — nobody wants the stress of wondering if rent will get paid on time. Messiness can turn your cozy home into a disaster zone, and sketchy references might mean trouble ahead. Spotting these red flags early can help ensure your living situation stays smooth and stress-free.

So, let’s dive in and explore the biggest roommate red flags to watch out for while you’re searching.

Poor communication skills

It’s not fun living with a roommate who dodges important conversations about bills, chores, or boundaries — it’s like being stuck in a never-ending game of charades. Picture this: Rent is due, and your roommate treats it like a state secret, or the sink is overflowing with dishes, but every time you mention it, they pull a disappearing act.

Roommate conflict of man and young woman at home.

Not being able to have straightforward discussions about daily essentials is like trying to assemble IKEA furniture without instructions — frustrating and prone to missing pieces. Having a roommate who can talk openly and responsibly about these matters is crucial. It keeps your home a peaceful sanctuary rather than a battleground. So, a roommate who shies away from these important chats is a major red flag to watch out for.

Financial instability

A potential roommate with a history of late payments, unstable employment, or a lack of transparency about their financial situation can be a major source of stress. Their unpredictable financial habits can lead to awkward conversations, unpaid bills, and mounting tension.

An adult man holds an open empty black leather wallet in his hands.

Living with someone whose financial stability is shaky feels like navigating a minefield — you’re never quite sure when the next issue will explode. Clear and reliable financial communication is crucial for a harmonious living arrangement. Without it, you might find yourself covering their share or dealing with the fallout of unpaid expenses.

Lack of cleanliness

A potential roommate who shows signs of being messy or unhygienic can create an uncomfortable and potentially unhealthy living environment. Nothing can be worse than coming home to dirty dishes piled high, laundry strewn about, and mysterious odors wafting through the apartment. This kind of messiness can make it hard to relax or entertain guests.

Woman annoyed at her roommate for leaving clothes around the house.

Beyond the discomfort, poor hygiene can also lead to health issues, like pests or mold. A clean and tidy home is essential for a pleasant and safe living experience, so a roommate who doesn’t maintain basic cleanliness is not an ideal choice.

Unreliable references

If previous landlords or roommates give negative feedback or seem hesitant, it can be a major warning sign. Nobody wants to ask for a reference and get lukewarm responses or hear about constant conflicts and issues, do they?

Woman looking unsure as she checks her roommate's references on her smartphone.

This kind of feedback suggests there might be underlying problems that could disrupt your living situation. Positive references are crucial for peace of mind, so if their past living arrangements raise concerns, maybe put your plans of moving in together on hold.

Disrespect for boundaries

No roommate is perfect, but one who ignores personal space, privacy, and shared living agreements crosses into nightmare territory. Could you even try to relax if you’re constantly having your room invaded, your belongings borrowed without permission, or your agreed-upon house rules blatantly disregarded? We don’t think so.

Roommates arguing over disrespected boundaries.

This lack of respect can lead to feelings of frustration and discomfort, making it hard to feel at home in your own space. Maintaining boundaries and honoring agreements are essential for a harmonious living environment.

Aggressive or hostile behavior

Displays of anger, aggression, or hostility, even in small doses during initial meetings, can indicate larger behavioral issues. Keep an eye out for potential roommates who react angrily over minor disagreements or show hostility in casual conversations.

Roommate becoming aggressive as they argue.

These early signs of aggressive behavior can foreshadow more serious conflicts down the road, creating a tense and uncomfortable living environment. It’s important to feel safe and at ease in your home, so any early indications of such negative behavior are major roommate red flags to consider.

Lack of responsibility

Whatever people say, being a responsible adult is hard. But that does not mean you should ignore signs that a potential roommate is not dependable, such as not showing up for meetings or being vague about their responsibilities. It can definitely lead to a lot of frustration when you’re trying to coordinate move-in dates or discuss shared chores, only to be met with missed appointments and evasive answers.

Bored young woman looking disappointed at her smart phone while waiting someone.

This lack of reliability can lead to ongoing frustration and confusion, making it difficult to maintain a smoothly running household. Dependability is crucial for a harmonious living arrangement, so if a potential roommate shows red flags regarding unreliability early on, it might be a sign to keep looking.

Pet issues

Pets are amazing companions, but if a potential roommate has pets and you are uncomfortable with animals, or if their pet has behavioral issues, it can pose a significant problem.

Dog stealing food from kitchen counter.

Behavioral issues like aggression or constant barking can disrupt your peace and potentially strain your relationship with your roommate. So, if pets or their behavior are a concern for you, it’s important to address this early on to avoid potential conflicts.

Lack of personal accountability

Can you imagine living with someone who deflects blame onto others whenever something goes wrong, or refuses to acknowledge their role in resolving issues? Doesn’t sound all that ideal. In fact, this behavior can lead to unresolved tensions and a lack of accountability in the household.

Roommates arguing at home.

A roommate who takes responsibility and communicates openly is essential for maintaining a respectful and cooperative living environment. Therefore, if you notice a pattern of blaming others or avoiding responsibility during discussions, it’s a significant roommate red flag to consider before committing to living together.

Finding the right roommate is crucial for creating a peaceful and enjoyable living environment. Remember, a good roommate should contribute positively to your shared space, ensuring that your home remains a comfortable sanctuary where both of you can thrive. So, trust your instincts and choose wisely to build a harmonious and happy living arrangement.

Share this article:

Adina Dragos is a creative writer at RentCafe, with a passion for reading, research and cats. As a fellow renter, Adina's articles cover various topics such as the state of the real estate market or how creative interior design choices improve the experience of living in a rental. She also enjoys exploring subjects like urbanization, green living and historical buildings. Adina has a BA in English and Norwegian Language and Literature.

Related posts

A construction crane working on a colorful, modern apartment building under a clear blue sky.

Protected: New Apartment Construction Breaks the 500K-Unit Mark; 2 Million Rentals to Open by 2028

There is no excerpt because this is a protected post.

Gorgeous view of Houston, Texas at sunrise.

Apartment Size in Texas: Where Can You Find the Largest Rentals?

When searching for a new apartment, size matters. In the Lone Star State, finding a spacious apartment can make all the difference in your living…

things to do in aurora colorado

9 Things to Do in Aurora, as Recommended by the Locals

Although it’s considered a suburb of Denver, Aurora, CO, is the third largest city in the state, with a population of over 380,000. Aurora was…